By Jess, Indiana watercolor artist and maker of Art and Home co. · Updated November 2026
The best Secret Santa or white elephant gift for women is something pretty and useful that anyone in the circle would be happy to take home. A hand-painted tea towel, a Christmas print, or a ceramic ornament gets stolen. A gag gift gets left on the table.
Here's how I'd pick one that gets fought over, in the nicest way.
What makes a white elephant gift get stolen?
Three things. It looks good the second it's unwrapped. Anyone in the room could use it. And it's not so personal that it only works for one person. Pretty and useful wins almost every time.
What are the best Secret Santa and white elephant gifts for women?
A Christmas tea towel. Everyone has a kitchen, and everyone needs a towel. The Merry Christmas Tea Towel and the Vintage Christmas Pattern Tea Towel look festive the moment the paper comes off.
A Christmas print. She can put it out that same night. The Merry Christmas print and the Vintage Christmas Tree print are both cozy and a little nostalgic.
A hand-painted ornament. This is the one people steal. It's one of a kind, so nobody else at the party will have it. See the ornament collection.
A 5x7 print for a tight budget. The easiest way to stay under the limit, and she can frame it that night. The Vintage Christmas Pattern print and the Journey to Bethlehem print are sweet ones.
An everyday tea towel. For the exchange that isn't Christmas-themed, The Peony State Tea Towel works all year.
How do I stay under the spending limit?
Check the price on the product page against your group's limit before you order. A single tea towel or a small print fits most exchanges without stretching. If you're under, tuck in a 5x7 print as a little extra.
What do I get for Secret Santa if I don't know her well?
Go with something seasonal and pretty, not personal. A Christmas towel or print works for the coworker you only see at the copier and for your best friend's mom. You don't need to know her taste to know she'll use it.
How should I wrap it so it gets picked?
Make it look good from across the room. Roll a tea towel and tie it with twine and a sprig of greenery. Put a print in a flat box with a ribbon. The prettiest package on the table usually gets picked first.
What's the difference between Secret Santa and white elephant?
In Secret Santa, you draw a name and shop for one person. In white elephant, everyone brings one gift for the pile, and people can steal gifts from each other. For Secret Santa, you can lean a little more personal. For white elephant, pick something everyone will want.
Shopping for more people on your list? Start with my Stocking Stuffers for Women and the Holiday Gift Guide for Women.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a good white elephant gift for women?
Something pretty and useful that anyone would want: a Christmas tea towel, a small Christmas print, or a hand-painted ornament.
What do you get a woman for Secret Santa if you don't know her well?
Keep it seasonal and pretty instead of personal. A Christmas tea towel or print works for almost anyone.
Is a tea towel a good Secret Santa gift?
Yes. Everyone has a kitchen, it looks festive when it's unwrapped, and she'll use it all season.
Where can I buy handmade Secret Santa gifts?
The Christmas collection is here. I paint every design in Indiana, and orders ship from my studio within a few business days.
Jess is an Indiana watercolor artist, a mom of two boys, and a minister's wife. She paints every design for Art and Home co. by hand. Created to give.